| Same-sex Civil Unions – Wednesday, 2nd July, 2008 | Joyce and Sybil Burden are two kindly old ladies facing a potentially nasty situation. Living in the same house all their lives, one of the pair faces an enormous inheritance tax bill when the other passes away. With no income beyond their pensions, the size of the bill means that one of them will have to sell the house to pay the taxman. |
| Failure to negotiate protocol leaves Irish social values vulnerable under Lisbon, Wednesday, 11th June 2008 | "People", according to the 19th century German statesman Otto von Bismarck, “never lie so much as after a hunt, during a war or before an election”. It's a cynical view, but watching the debate over the Lisbon Treaty, you get the depressing feeling that Bismarck had a point.
Instead of an open and informed debate on the merits of the Lisbon Treaty, we have been treated to a display of mudslinging, red herrings and disinformation. It’s been a poor advertisement for democracy. |
| Broadcasting Bill should ensure fairness and balance in the treatment of sensitive social issues, Wednesday, 4th June, 2008 | Legendary movie mogul Darryl F Zanuck, founder of 20th Century Fox studios predicted in the 1940s that television wouldn’t take hold – “People will soon get tired of staring at a plywood box every night.” In the decades that followed, television made a mug out of Zanuck, as it went on to become the most powerful medium of the 20th century.
In recent years, we have become so entranced with a 21st century medium, the internet, that we have grown almost blasé about the continued power of TV. So much so that discussion of new legislation in the area of broadcasting seems to be confined to our politicians, with the public thoroughly disengaged. |
| Ireland mustn’t follow the ‘Dirty Harry’ model of criminal justice, Wednesday 28th May 2008 | “The question is, do you feel lucky, punk?” With these words, Clint Eastwood helped to symbolise the American ‘get tough’ policy on crime. Made in the mid-1970s Eastwood's Dirty Harry films, along with the Death Wish films of Charles Bronson, embodied in film the frustration that many US voters felt about soaring crime rates. America was as mad as hell, and wasn't going to take it any more. |
|
|
|
As a columnist in the Irish Daily Mail and previously with the Irish Examiner, it has been my job to reflect on the issues of the day and give my views. You can read some of my articles which I have reproduced here, courtesy of the Mail and Examiner.
|
|
|
|
| Same-sex Civil Unions – Wednesday, 2nd July, 2008 |
|
Same-sex Civil Unions – Wednesday, 2nd July, 2008
|
|
Joyce and Sybil Burden are two kindly old ladies facing a potentially nasty situation. Living in the same house all their lives, one of the pair faces an enormous inheritance tax bill when the other passes away. With no income beyond their pensions, the size of the bill means that one of them will have to sell the house to pay the taxman.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Failure to negotiate protocol leaves Irish social values vulnerable under Lisbon, Wednesday, 11th June 2008 |
|
Failure to negotiate protocol leaves Irish social values vulnerable under Lisbon, Wednesday, 11th June 2008
|
|
"People", according to the 19th century German statesman Otto von Bismarck, “never lie so much as after a hunt, during a war or before an election”. It's a cynical view, but watching the debate over the Lisbon Treaty, you get the depressing feeling that Bismarck had a point.
Instead of an open and informed debate on the merits of the Lisbon Treaty, we have been treated to a display of mudslinging, red herrings and disinformation. It’s been a poor advertisement for democracy.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Broadcasting Bill should ensure fairness and balance in the treatment of sensitive social issues, Wednesday, 4th June, 2008 |
|
Broadcasting Bill should ensure fairness and balance in the treatment of sensitive social issues, Wednesday, 4th June, 2008
|
|
Legendary movie mogul Darryl F Zanuck, founder of 20th Century Fox studios predicted in the 1940s that television wouldn’t take hold – “People will soon get tired of staring at a plywood box every night.” In the decades that followed, television made a mug out of Zanuck, as it went on to become the most powerful medium of the 20th century.
In recent years, we have become so entranced with a 21st century medium, the internet, that we have grown almost blasé about the continued power of TV. So much so that discussion of new legislation in the area of broadcasting seems to be confined to our politicians, with the public thoroughly disengaged.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Ireland mustn’t follow the ‘Dirty Harry’ model of criminal justice, Wednesday 28th May 2008 |
|
|
|
| Congratulations Mr Cowen – and now some advice, 7 May 2008 |
|
Congratulations Mr Cowen – and now some advice, 7 May 2008
|
|
Dear Mr Cowen,
First of all, congratulations on your ascent to the highest office in Irish politics. Over the course of over 85 years, only 11 other persons have attained this position. It’s a rare honour, and a unique responsibility, that you receive today.
After the congratulations, however, will come the challenges, and these are formidable.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Bioethics Council recommendations unprincipled, unnecessary and divisive, Wednesday, 30th April, 2008 |
|
Bioethics Council recommendations unprincipled, unnecessary and divisive, Wednesday, 30th April, 2008
|
|
Legendary automotive tycoon and business pioneer Henry Ford wasn't a slavish devotee to the maxim that the customer is always right. He famously told potential buyers of his revolutionary Model T Ford, one of the first mass-produced and relatively affordable cars, that they could have the car in any colour "as long as it's black".
It appears that, in Ireland, we're being given a similar Hobson's choice on the issue of embryonic stem cell research. Last week, the Irish Council for Bioethics (ICB), issued a report recommending that scientists be allowed to carry out destructive research on human embryos, on the basis that embryonic stem cell research was the "gold standard" when it came to stem cell science.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Court decision in favour of lesbian couple blind to the true needs of children, Wednesday, 23rd April, 2008 |
|
Court decision in favour of lesbian couple blind to the true needs of children, Wednesday, 23rd April, 2008
|
|
The law has a way of dealing with contracts which it holds are illegal or immoral. It can refuse to enforce them. In one infamous case in the 19th century, a coach builder hired out a coach to a woman in prostitution for the purpose of enabling her, in the restrained words of one of the judges, "to make a display favourable to her immoral purposes." The coach builder later sued her for monies payable under the agreement. The courts ruled that he couldn't recover the price agreed, on the basis that he had full knowledge of the nefarious purposes for which his coach was being used.
Are modern judges more reluctant to consider the moral dimensions of contracts? Just last week, a biological father who sought guardianship and access rights to his child lost his case in the High Court.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| ‘Early immersion’ in Irish enhances, not retards, a child’s language-learning ability, Wednesday, 16th April, 2008 |
|
‘Early immersion’ in Irish enhances, not retards, a child’s language-learning ability, Wednesday, 16th April, 2008
|
|
Some years ago, Irish director Daniel O'Hara made a short film called My Name is Yu Ming. The central character, a Chinese shopkeeper, decides to move to Ireland. On learning that Irish is the first official language of the State, he resolves to learn the Gaeilge. But, on arriving here, he quickly learns that no one speaks it. In fact, they think he is speaking Chinese.
At 13 minutes long, the film is a devastating critique of our treatment of our native language. A quick look at the Constitution shows that Irish is the first language. But Des Bishop's current series, In the Name of the Fada, illustrates the extent to which the State has failed in its aim to teach pupils how to use and speak our first language in an everyday way.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Media spin obscures respect for diversity in denominational education, Wednesday, 2nd April, 2008 |
|
Media spin obscures respect for diversity in denominational education, Wednesday, 2nd April, 2008
|
|
Cork-reared US radical journalist Alexander Cockburn makes a nice caustic remark about his profession. The first law of journalism, he says, is "to confirm existing prejudice, rather than contradict it".
There was an example of this in a recent front-page headline in the Irish Independent, alleging that the Catholic Church was "seeking a veto" on, among other things, the appointment of teachers in any new VEC-run primary schools in Dublin.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| China must be encouraged to embrace true Olympic ideals, Wednesday, 26th March 2008 |
|
China must be encouraged to embrace true Olympic ideals, Wednesday, 26th March 2008
|
|
“China is changing the world towards a path of repression,” was the cry from one of the Tibetan protesters who upstaged the lighting of the Olympic flame on Monday. The flame-lighting in Greece was meant to symbolise the transfer of the Olympic ideal from Athens, where the Games were held in 2004, to Beijing, where they are scheduled to be held in August.
The focus was meant to be on the Olympic ideal, and on the pride and effort of athletes. Instead, the flame became a spotlight on the issue of human rights abuses.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Planning policies must prioritise Quality of Life issues, Wednesday, 19th March, 2008 |
|
Planning policies must prioritise Quality of Life issues, Wednesday, 19th March, 2008
|
|
According to one online poll last week, a majority of voters oppose St Patrick's Day trips abroad by Government ministers. The voters don’t, unfortunately, agree that these trips allow Ireland to develop trade and cultural links with other countries. All the voters see are costly taxpayer-funded junkets, it seems.
But even the hardest of hearts would hardly begrudge the Taoiseach his visit to the United States last Monday. After another tough week, which saw yet more details revealed about his complicated personal finances, the man clearly needed a break.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| A tax on child benefit would be the opposite of common sense, Wednesday, 5th March, 2008 |
|
A tax on child benefit would be the opposite of common sense, Wednesday, 5th March, 2008
|
|
Back in 1992, the late Brian Lenihan Snr said Ireland would be “the laughing stock of Europe” if we failed to endorse the Maastricht Treaty. That was before both the Danes and the French voted ‘No’. For one wag at the time, this meant that a ‘Yes’ vote would make us the laughing stock of Europe.
During the 1980s and 1990s, legions of commentators bemoaned the fact that Ireland lagged behind other countries - culturally, economically and socially. But it’s a long time since Ireland was an international laughing stock. Our continental competitors, with economic growth rates inferior to ours, have little reason to laugh. Despite the economic woes that result from a international slowdown, Ireland continues to have an economy that stands comparison with any in the world.
Yet a recent report from a Government think-tank suggests that some top advisers may want Ireland to go back to being ‘Paddy-last’. A study from the National Economic and Social Council (NESC) says that our child benefit scheme is “hugely inefficient” at reducing poverty, since it is paid to all families regardless of income. Instead of putting more money into the child benefit system, NESC says, the State should create a new “second tier” system for lower income families.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Rights for all mutually dependent couples the key issue in same sex union debate, Wednesday, 27th February, 2008 |
|
Rights for all mutually dependent couples the key issue in same sex union debate, Wednesday, 27th February, 2008
|
|
Can I marry a tree? In one sense, the answer, surprisingly, is yes. In a recent essay on the subject of same sex marriage, Dr Neville Cox, a senior lecturer in Trinity College, says that marriage is all about definitions. If you define marriage as a union that can take place between you and any other animate or inanimate object, then you can marry anyone or anything.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| ABA as important as ABC for many schoolchildren with autism, Wednesday, 20thFebruary, 2008 |
|
ABA as important as ABC for many schoolchildren with autism, Wednesday, 20thFebruary, 2008
|
|
“Finding out that your child has a disability is one of the most difficult things that any parent could have to deal with.” Those understanding words were written in the Irish Times on Monday, by the Minister for Education Mary Hanafin. They show an admirable level of compassion and empathy. Sadly, they do not appear to reflect the attitude of her Department to parents who find themselves in the position the Minister describes.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Bunreacht na hEireann has let us speak of human rights in our own distinctive voice, Wednesday, 30th January, 2008 |
|
Bunreacht na hEireann has let us speak of human rights in our own distinctive voice, Wednesday, 30th January, 2008
|
There’s a story about Eamon De Valera, on the first of two occasions when Fianna Fáil tried to get rid of proportional representation by a referendum of the people. The Dublin Opinion, or some other journal, carried a cartoon depicting Dev the mathematician, complete with mortarboard, writing out an equation: FF minus PR, he wrote, equals infinity.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Palestinians need promise of prosperity to come out for peace, Wednesday, 16th January, 2008 |
|
Palestinians need promise of prosperity to come out for peace, Wednesday, 16th January, 2008
|
|
Former US President Bill Clinton is fondly remembered on these shores for his tireless work in getting the Northern Ireland peace process off the ground. But at times, even Clinton grew weary of the endless stream of seemingly minor quarrels which attended the process. He once compared the two sides to “a couple of drunks walking out of a bar for the last time. When they reach the swing doors they turn right around and go back in and say 'I just can't quite get there'.”
If that's what he thought of the protagonists on either side of the Northern Ireland conflict, one shudders to think how he might describe those involved in the Israeli-Palestinian dispute.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Taxing Times for Family Life |
|
Taxing Times for Family Life
|
|
In practice now, a married couple with children, surviving on a single-income, could be paying €6,240 more tax each year than a double income couple, with or without children, with the same total earnings. Tax individualisation diminishes and disregards the unpaid work being done by the parent who chooses to stay at home. This country is awash with money, and we can well afford a rethink on how we are treating families. It’s time we made choices in favour of the next generation.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Effective Penal Reform |
|
Effective Penal Reform
|
|
We’re having a phoney war on crime, and a faux debate over how to fight it. Treating criminals like outcasts, and putting the emphasis on tougher sentences might satiate some people’s anger. But it ignores the reality that, at present, our prison system simply turns petty offenders into more hardened criminals. A proper rehabilitation policy would mean less re-offending, which in turn would mean less crime.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Alcohol Advertising & Young People |
|
Alcohol Advertising & Young People
|
|
Given the considerable and ever-growing economic, social and health costs associated with alcohol abuse in Ireland, our politicians must be bolder. It’s time to ban, or drastically curtail, alcohol advertising aimed at young drinkers.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| The Real Quality of Life Agenda |
|
The Real Quality of Life Agenda
|
|
The quality of life agenda isn't just about one-off measures such as tackling transport or equalising tax for stay-at-home parents. It's about wider cultural questions. Isn't there a link between the priority we give to family, community and the raising our children - and the way we treat each other? Our high-growth, low unemployment economy has brought many benefits, and we should strive to maintain it. But the policies of progress need to be put in a more holistic and convincing context.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Government's Failure over Sex Trafficking |
|
Government's Failure over Sex Trafficking
|
|
To break the cycle of trafficking, other countries have allowed temporary residency to abused women, plus reflection periods to allow them recover from the problems linked with captivity and exploitation – disorientation, trauma and mistrust. Our Government’s failure to legislate, in line with internationally recognised standards, is inexcusable.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Alcohol & Young People |
|
Alcohol & Young People
|
|
The issue now is, in the aftermath of the death of Brian Murphy, are we going to focus on
the one person who was found guilty and satisfy ourselves that justice
has been done? Or are we going to concentrate on the thousands who act
in a dangerously similar manner – and resolve to change things?
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Special Olympics |
|
Special Olympics
|
|
"Even as we celebrate the lives of people
with Down syndrome and other conditions, there is a worrying trend in
our society to see such people as a problem, a burden on resources,
rather than as people with their own gifts who can enrich society in
their own way."
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Citizenship Referendum |
|
Citizenship Referendum
|
|
"The use of words such as 'citizenship tourism' suggests people are trying to access Ireland and the EU out of some kind of lifestyle choice. In fact, they are trying to escape poverty."
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Valuing Our Senior Citizens |
|
|
|
| Arms Trade |
|
Arms Trade
|
|
"The defenders of western civilisation in
the war against terrorism don't seem to make the link between chaos in
the world and their own refusal to clamp down on the sale of arms. The
G-8 countries account for 90% of 'licit' arms sales. But while they see
a difference between selling arms to legitimate governments and the
black market sale of arms to terrorist groups, the truth is that one is
often the starting point for the other."
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Immigration |
|
Immigration
|
|
We should reject a simplistic distinction between
deserving ‘asylum seekers’ and undeserving ‘economic migrants’.
Desperate poverty and human rights abuses can also amount to persecution.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Asylum Policy |
|
Asylum Policy
|
Sadly our asylum system is evidence that it is our own industrial needs rather than our international conscience which drives our approach to immigration and the poor who travel here to seek a better life in Ireland.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Sensible Planning |
|
Sensible Planning
|
|
Development should take place in a staged
way, with permission for new phases only given once proper amenities are
in place. A real commitment is required by the Government
to give families and communities the space they need to live and thrive.
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Childcare |
|
Childcare
|
|
"It seems obvious that any use of state
funds for childcare must be fairly distributed between those who
sacrifice an income to bring up their children and those who go out to
work and use childcare."
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
| Prison Reform |
|
Prison Reform
|
|
"The
wider community must take responsibility for prisoners, including the
drug-abusers, if rehabilitation of prisoners is to happen."
|
| Read
More.. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|